Chrystal and I were talking earlier today and we both mentioned blogs we were in the process of writing. Interestingly enough, they were almost exactly the same, mostly having to do with nutrition, and how strongly people feel about how they eat. Even more interesting than that, Chrystal and I have close to 100 pounds that separate what we weigh. We are both healthy, we both eat processed foods from time to time, we both drink Diet Coke, we both have people who very adamantly tell us how we should be eating.
Here is Chrystal’s original blog:
When did fitness and nutrition become a religion? Typically (or perhaps I should say stereotypically) people believe in their particular “religion” or beliefs so sincerely, they feel their way is the only way. Religion is something that is very personal. It comes together from childhood, family beliefs, social surroundings, self awareness, personal research, etc. The beliefs are formed and probably tweaked along the way. (Sort of like our eating habits.) Whatever your religion, you BELIEVE in it. If someone told you your beliefs were wrong, you would probably defend them passionately. However, if you explored other religions you might find one aspect of it that makes sense to you intellectually.
Fitness and nutrition have suddenly become the same (or am I just noticing this)? Paleo and vegetarians seem to be in some kind of war against each other. Their schools of thought are so completely different, yet they are passionate THEIR way is the best (and only) way to fuel your body. Each can provide mounds of research to back up their thinking. So, how can that be? How can research prove that both are awesome for your body? Because either one can be awesome for your body. There are perfect examples of phenomenal athletes on both sides. Olympian Amanda Beard eats a Paleo diet. Wait a second. Amanda Beard eats a vegetarian diet. Actually, I have no idea what Amanda Beard currently eats. Obviously both diets have served her well. (Hello? She’s an Olympian!)
Here’s the point – you have to find what works for YOU! I rarely eat meat anymore. Meat doesn’t agree with my digestive system. Does that mean I think you should give up meat? Um…yeah, I can’t even imagine telling my husband that. If meat works for you, then I think that’s awesome. I know lots of super hot people who eat lean meats. It works for them. I’m not going to tell them they’re going to hell they can’t be fit, or hot, or awesome if they eat meat. Just like I hope you aren’t going to tell me I can’t build muscle by eating a mostly vegetarian diet. There’s more than one way to skin a cat so to speak (sorry, vegetarians).
Clean eating is AWESOME! In theory. I would love to eat clean(er). The reality is, I eat frozen meals for lunch. Usually washed down with a diet coke. (I’ll wait while you spew out your coconut water.) Now, before you preach to me about artificial this and processed that, just know that I get where you’re coming from. BUT this works for me. Could I be better? Hell yes! I bet you could too. But there’s this little thing called life and I have to live it. I have to decide how extreme or not I want to live. I know that if I don’t eat completely clean, I’m probably not going to have totally crazy ripped abs. I’m okay with my flat(ish) abs.
Whether you are a Baptist or a Catholic, a vegetarian or a Paleo, please know that there is no ONE way that works for everyone. There’s a reason there’s freedom of religion in the constitution. So, don’t make me bust out my feather pen and write up a nutrition rule book!
And here is mine (originally title “How Does This Thing Work”):
By “this”, I mean weight loss.
As for working…it doesnt, you do.
There are tons of products/diets/theories/workouts that claim to help you lose weight. Some free, some expensive, some dangerous to your health.
There are also tons of studies “proving” why this plan is better than that plan, or telling you your body needs to be fueled a certain way to lose fat/perform better/yada yada yada.
The kicker? Most of them are right.
How, you ask? Pretty much every plan can work for at least one person…if that persons wants to lose weight bad enough and works for it.
Weight Watchers works…if you are willing to follow the points system.
Jenny Craig works…if you are willing to pay what it costs and eat Jenny Craig food.
Diet pills work…if you exercise and eat well…some at a cost to your health.
Exercise works…if you put in the work, and don’t eat back all the calories you burn.
Paleo works…if you are willing to eat low/no carbs and high fat foods.
Clean eating works…if you are willing to put in the time for food prep and follow specific guidelines.
The Subway diet.
Slim Fast
Nutrisystem
Hcg
South Beach
The Twinkie diet
Etc etc
You’ve probably heard of all or at least some of these. Somewhere, there is someone who has had success with each and every one of them. Here are my thoughts on this:
- If I search the internet long enough, I can find a study that says everything is bad for me. Then, I can probably find a study that said that thing that was just bad for me, is actually good for me.
- This is not my first barbecue. I’ve lost weight before. Not on a diet, and no I didn’t get fat again after losing the weight because I stopped doing what I needed to do. I lost 40 pounds in 5 months by logging my food and exercising, and sticking to around 1700 calories/day during the week. I didn’t log on weekends. Did I give up anything? Nope. I still ate cake, I still ate McDonald’s (yes, I can see your eye rolls from here), I just logged everything, tried to make the best choices when I did eat bad, and watched how MUCH I ate. It WORKED.
- I’ve lost over 40 pounds this time around, doing it pretty much the same way, except up until about a week ago, I wasn’t really logging or paying *that much* attention to calories.
The thing that people have to understand is that just because it works for you, or you think it is the best way, doesn’t mean that is the ONLY way for every single person. I’ve chosen to do this mostly with exercise. Why? Because that is where I’ve had the success. That is the part that is easiest for me. That is what I have been able to do consistently for 8 months. I don’t talk about food a lot because I know there are a lot of people who probably think I’m doing it the “wrong” way, and want to persuade me to come over to their way of thinking. Why would I change if I am having success doing what I am doing? I’m perfectly healthy, I have a level of fitness that is on par with some people half my size, and I’m happy. I’m a busy mom of 2, and I do the best I can with what resources I have. The resource I’m short on most is time. What I do, is what fits into my lifestyle. What you do, is what fits into your lifestyle. I don’t pass judgment on anyone else for their food choices, because it’s a personal decision, and unless you have an eating disorder, that has absolutely nothing to do with me. Just as what I eat should have no bearing on your life. It truly is okay to have different ways of doing things.
Your Two Fit Freaks ~ Tiffany & Chrystal
Written by Workout Girl
1 Comment